In short
Three agents will give you three different valuations and three different fees, and the highest valuation is often the one that ends in a price reduction. These questions turn a sales pitch into a comparison you can score. Take one printed copy into each appointment and write the answers straight onto it.
Last updated . Reviewed by FindYourAgent editorial.
Print one per valuation
Three agents, three printed copies, one honest comparison. No email required.
On the valuation
Which three sold comparables did you price this on, and when did they complete?
- Strong answer
- Names streets and completion dates within the last six months, and explains the adjustments up or down.
- Worth worrying about
- Talks about "what the market is doing" or shows asking prices rather than sold prices.
What is your sale-price-to-asking-price ratio for the last six months in this postcode?
- Strong answer
- A figure between roughly 94% and 100%, offered without hesitation.
- Worth worrying about
- Cannot produce a number, or quotes a national average.
How many of your last ten instructions had a price reduction before they sold?
- Strong answer
- Answers honestly, including the ones that were reduced, and explains why.
- Worth worrying about
- Claims none. Every agent reduces some.
What would you list at if you wanted it sold in six weeks rather than six months?
- Strong answer
- Gives two clear numbers and the trade-off between them.
- Worth worrying about
- Insists the higher figure will sell just as fast.
On the fee and the contract
What is the fee, including VAT, in pounds on your suggested asking price?
- Strong answer
- A pound figure, stated plainly, with VAT included.
- Worth worrying about
- A percentage only, or "we can discuss that later".
Is that fee negotiable if I instruct today?
- Strong answer
- Most will move 0.1–0.3 percentage points. Ask, then stop talking.
- Worth worrying about
- Refuses to discuss it while pushing for a same-day signature.
How long is the tie-in period, and what notice do I give after it?
- Strong answer
- 8–12 weeks tie-in, 14 days' notice, both written into the agreement.
- Worth worrying about
- 16 weeks or more, or notice that only starts after the tie-in ends.
Is this sole agency or sole selling rights?
- Strong answer
- Sole agency. Sole selling rights means a fee is owed even if you find the buyer yourself.
- Worth worrying about
- Uses the two terms interchangeably or brushes the distinction aside.
Are there withdrawal fees, marketing charges or a ready-willing-and-able buyer clause?
- Strong answer
- No, or discloses them and points to the clause in the agreement.
- Worth worrying about
- Says no while the clause sits in the contract. Read it yourself.
On the marketing
Which portals will the property appear on, and is that included?
- Strong answer
- Rightmove and at least one of Zoopla or OnTheMarket, all included.
- Worth worrying about
- Portal placement charged as an extra.
Who takes the photographs, and can I see three recent examples from your office?
- Strong answer
- Professional photographer, floorplan included, and shows examples without being asked twice.
- Worth worrying about
- Phone photos taken by the valuer during the appraisal.
Who writes the listing copy, and do I approve it before it goes live?
- Strong answer
- Yes, and they expect you to.
- Worth worrying about
- Copy goes live unseen.
How soon after instruction will it be on the portals?
- Strong answer
- Within five working days, launched on a Thursday or Friday.
- Worth worrying about
- No commitment, or a launch date that keeps slipping.
On viewings and offers
Who conducts viewings, and are evenings and weekends covered?
- Strong answer
- An accompanied member of staff, with Saturday cover as standard.
- Worth worrying about
- Expects you to host every viewing while charging a full fee.
How quickly do I get written feedback after each viewing?
- Strong answer
- Within 24 hours, in writing, unedited.
- Worth worrying about
- Verbal, when you chase.
How do you verify a buyer's mortgage and chain position before I accept?
- Strong answer
- Mortgage in principle, proof of deposit and a written chain summary.
- Worth worrying about
- Takes the buyer's word for it.
Who chases the sale through to completion, and can I have their direct line?
- Strong answer
- A named sales progressor with a direct number and a weekly update habit.
- Worth worrying about
- "The team" handles it.
On performance you can verify yourself
How many properties have you sold in this postcode in the last twelve months?
- Strong answer
- A number you can sanity-check against sold listings on the portals.
- Worth worrying about
- A branch-wide or region-wide figure used to dodge the local one.
What is your average time from listing to sale agreed here?
- Strong answer
- Typically 4–10 weeks. A precise figure suggests they measure it.
- Worth worrying about
- "It depends" with no number attached.
What proportion of your agreed sales fell through last year?
- Strong answer
- Around a quarter is normal in the UK. Honesty matters more than the number.
- Worth worrying about
- Claims almost none fall through.
Which redress scheme are you a member of?
- Strong answer
- The Property Ombudsman or the Property Redress Scheme. Membership is a legal requirement.
- Worth worrying about
- Not sure. Walk away.
Scoring the three valuations
Once you have three sets of answers, ignore the headline valuations for a moment and rank the agents on three things: their sale-to-asking ratio, their average days to sold in your postcode, and whether they gave you numbers or adjectives. The agent with the best two of those three is usually the one who nets you the most, even when their valuation was not the highest in the room.
Then negotiate the fee. A 0.2 percentage-point reduction on a £300,000 sale is £600 plus VAT, and it costs one sentence: "I have three quotes in front of me — is that your best fee?"
Free agent matching
See what your home could be worth
Get a free indicative valuation in about 60 seconds. See your estimate before deciding whether you want introductions to local agents.
Free for sellers. We pass your details to our partner GetAgent (Move with Us Ltd), who introduce you to up to 3 estate agents operating in your postcode area. Agents pay GetAgent a referral fee only on a successful sale — you never pay more than normal commission. How we make money.